Confirmed attendees
- Leanne Guy (co-chair)
- Eli Rykoff (co-chair)
- Zeljko Ivezic
- Patrick Ingraham
- Chris Stubbs
- James Chiang
- Robert Lupton
- Aaron Roodman
- Steve Ritz
- Lynne Jones
- Peter Yoachim
- Merlin Fisher-Levine
- Parker Fagrelius
- Pierre Antilogus
- Elana Urbach
- Agnès Ferté
- Andrés Alejandro Plazas Malagón
Virtual
- Jim Bosch
- Christopher Waters
- David Burke
- Clare Saunders
- Douglas Tucker (probably mostly just listening in)
- John Parejko (mostly listening)
- Keith Bechtol
Logistics
Date : 2022-08-25/26
Location: SLAC in-person and hybrid
SLAC rooms: We have three rooms reserved in Bld. 53 all day for both days
- 3004- Havasu ( 3rd floor) : Primary room, coffee/food location ( Zoom- # 1)
- 4002- Toluca-( 4th floor) : Breakout room - ( Zoom - #2)
- 4006- Tulare ( 4th floor) : Breakout room- ( Zoom- #3)
Zoom channels:
Calibration workshop # 1
https://stanford.zoom.us/j/94091115031?pwd=R0tUS1R2RFRDMUpRMW8xQVVBbVRHdz09
Password: 271390
Or Telephone:
Dial: +1 650 724 9799 (US, Canada, Caribbean Toll) or +1 833 302 1536 (US, Canada, Caribbean Toll Free)
Meeting ID: 940 9111 5031
Password: 271390
Calibration Workshop # 2
Join from PC, Mac, Linux, iOS or Android: https://stanford.zoom.us/j/96167369631?pwd=ZzNwL3M4Q2JYbG9GODFxNllhTG1iZz09
Password: 948060
Or Telephone:
Dial: +1 650 724 9799 (US, Canada, Caribbean Toll) or +1 833 302 1536 (US, Canada, Caribbean Toll Free)
Meeting ID: 961 6736 9631
Password: 948060
Calibration Workshop # 3
Join from PC, Mac, Linux, iOS or Android: https://stanford.zoom.us/j/99821797751?pwd=dC94cEExRW5LYUhtb1ZSTnhsbDY5UT09
Password: 810284
Or Telephone:
Dial: +1 650 724 9799 (US, Canada, Caribbean Toll) or +1 833 302 1536 (US, Canada, Caribbean Toll Free)
Meeting ID: 998 2179 7751
Password: 810284
Resources
- Google drive for materials
- Workshop slide deck
- Slack channel: #rubinobs-calibpalooza
- IT Support : Nabil (available from 7:30)
Workshop Goals
The goal of the workshop is to define and document the full end-to-end strategy for LSST calibration, from ISR through global astrometric and photometric calibrations. The workshop aims to identify what needs to be addressed and how the different stages of calibration relate to each other, not precisely how to address them. For example, a list of effects that need to be corrected for in ISR is in scope, but not necessarily the precise algorithms that will be used.
Desired Outcomes:
- Flowchart for the end-to-end calibration strategy
- An initial draft of the LSST Calibration construction paper defining the full LSST end-to-end calibration strategy.
Workshop Covid Policy
The workshop will follow Current Stanford Covid-19 guidelines for visitors. All in-person attendees must:
- present proof of vaccination cards in the Bldg 53 lobby to enter SLAC;
- wear a mask during the meeting as per SLAC guidelines
Pre-workshop reading material
The following is a list of extant material on LSST calibration that attendees should be familiar with prior to the workshop.
Required reading before the workshop
- Instrumental response model and detrending for the Dark Energy Camera (Bernstein et al. 2017)
- An excellent pedagogical description of how to do darks, flats, illumination correction, photometric calibration, etc.
- The paper is focused on what was run for DES, but is much broader than that, with a comprehensive glossary and descriptions of how everything fits together.
- LSST The Hyper Suprime-Cam Software Pipeline (Bosch et al. 2017):
- A good description of the LSST Science Pipelines as of 2017.
- Note that Jointcal is no longer in the baseline and PSFex has been replaced with PIFF.
- The deblending section is not relevant to calibration so can be skipped (and the deblender has been changed anyway)
- The coaddition sections are also interesting but not necessary to know in detail for this workshop.
- 4.9.2 : Aperture corrections are a very important part of calibration
- A good description of the LSST Science Pipelines as of 2017.
- Level 2 Photometric Calibration for the LSST Survey : LSE-180 (Jones et al. 2013)
- LSST baseline for photometric calibration in 2013.
- Many aspects are still relevant but it needs updating.
- This technote can be used as a basis for much of the updated end-to-end calibration strategy.
- The document source lives at https://github.com/lsst-sims/sims_documents (other docs also, including potentially useful python too)
Additional relevant material:
- Eli's talk on photometrics calibration at the Rubin Algorithms Workshop
- The state of Rubin Calibration: PST talk, 2021
- ISR, DM & Camera: PST talk 2021 ISPST R: D
- Instrument Signature Removal Listing
- Focal Plane Anomalies and Effects: post Cryostat EO testing
- LSST plans for calibrated photometry
- Calibration Generation, Verification, Acceptance, and Certification.
- Verifying LSST Calibration Data Products - possibly superseded by the above
- Astrometric calibration and performance of the Dark Energy Camera
- Photometric Characterization of the Dark Energy Camera
Workshop Planning, Agenda and Minutes
- Pre-workshop topics
- Workshop Agenda and Minutes
- Breakout 1 <topic> - running notes
- Breakout 2 <topic>- running notes
- Breakout 2 <topic>- running notes
- Breakout 4 <topic>- running notes